All Coin Categories

Best Sellers

All best sellers

Coin and Bullion Mints

Buffalo Nickels (1913 to 1938) | The Coin Shop

Buffalo Nickels

The Buffalo Nickel or Indian Head Nickel is a copper-nickel five-cent piece that was struck by the United States Mint from 1913 to 1938. It was designed by sculptor James Earle Fraser. The Buffalo Nickel is very popular among today's collectors. The older the Buffalo Nickel the better, but the age by itself does not determine value. If you are in possession of a Buffalo coin struck during the first few years of mintage, that has somehow been carefully preserved, you likely have a top-valued Buffalo Nickel.

Active filters

1913-P Var. 2 Buffalo Nickel 1913-P Type 2 Buffalo Nickel

1913-P Type 2 Buffalo Nickel

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$5.00 Price

Add this 1913-P Type 2 Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1913-D Var. 1 Buffalo Nickel 1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel

1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$10.00 Price

Add this 1913-D Type 1 Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1913-D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel 1913-D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel KEY DATE

1913-D Type 2 Buffalo...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$120.00 Price

1913-D Type 2 Buffalo Nickel*Stock image shown. Please select an available grade below

1913-S Var. 1 Buffalo Nickel 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel Semi-Key Date

1913-S Type 1 Buffalo...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$20.00 Price

Add this 1913-S Type 1 Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel 1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel KEY DATE
  • New

1913-S Type 2 Buffalo...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$150.00 Price

1913-S Type 2 Buffalo Nickel *Stock image shown. Please select from available grades below.

1914-P Buffalo Nickel 1914-P Buffalo Nickel

1914-P Buffalo Nickel

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$15.50 Price

Add this 1914-P Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1914-D Buffalo Nickel 1914-D Buffalo Nickel KEY DATE

1914-D Buffalo Nickel KEY DATE

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$70.00 Price

Add this 1914-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1914-S Buffalo Nickel 1914-S Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1914-S Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$12.00 Price

Add this 1914-S Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1915-P Buffalo Nickel 1915-P Buffalo Nickel

1915-P Buffalo Nickel

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$3.00 Price

Add this 1915-P Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1915-D Buffalo Nickel 1915-D Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1915-D Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$9.00 Price

Add this 1915-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1915-S Buffalo Nickel 1915-S Buffalo Nickel Semi-Key Date

1915-S Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$32.00 Price

Add this 1915-S Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1916-D Buffalo Nickel 1916-D Buffalo Nickel Tough Date

1916-D Buffalo Nickel Tough...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$10.00 Price

Add this 1916-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1916-S Buffalo Nickel 1916-S Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1916-S Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$5.50 Price

Add this 1916-S Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1917-D Buffalo Nickel 1917-D Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1917-D Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$10.00 Price

Add this 1917-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1917-S Buffalo Nickel 1917-S Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1917-S Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$12.50 Price

Add this 1917-S Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1918-P Buffalo Nickel 1918-P Buffalo Nickel

1918-P Buffalo Nickel

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$2.75 Price

Add this 1918-P Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1918-D Buffalo Nickel 1918-D Buffalo Nickel Semi-Key Date

1918-D Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$16.50 Price

Add this 1918-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1918-S Buffalo Nickel 1918-S Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1918-S Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$8.00 Price

Add this 1918-S Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.

1919-D Buffalo Nickel 1919-D Buffalo Nickel Better Date

1919-D Buffalo Nickel...

Please notify me when this product is in stock.
Temporarily Sold Out
$9.50 Price

Add this 1919-D Buffalo Nickel to your Nickel collection.Stock image shown. Please select a grade.